HEAD-TO-HEAD · DILDOS

Mr Hankey's Toys vs Vixen Creations

By Sasha & Daniel

Verdict drawn from our full reviews of both brands

THE VERDICT

The two best silicone dildo makers in the world, split by what you want the dildo to be. For realism, Vixen. VixSkin's soft-over-firm dual density is the most convincing material in the industry and Vixen's lineup is built entirely around that feel. For everything else, Mr Hankey's, with hyper-realistic lifecasts and fantasy creatures in the same catalog, firmness and color chosen per order, Vac-U-Lock bases, and a size range from 5 inches to sizes that need a safe word. Vixen's range is narrow and non-motorized; Hankey's matte silicone is a lint magnet and nothing good starts under $125. Neither accepts returns. Neither will disappoint you on quality.

Mr Hankey's Toys

9.2

GREAT

$60–$300

Vixen Creations

8.8

GREAT

$65–$150

KEY DIFFERENCES

Mr Hankey's Toys leads overall, 9.2 to 8.8.
Typical prices: Mr Hankey's Toys $60–$300, Vixen Creations $65–$150.
Different specialties: Mr Hankey's Toys is reviewed as Fantasy Dildos, Vixen Creations as Dildos.
Mr Hankey's Toys wins Value for Money: 8 vs 7.

SCORE BREAKDOWN

Value for Money

PROS & CONS

MR HANKEY'S TOYS

PROS

✓The finest platinum-cured silicone I’ve ever touched: hand-poured in California, ISO-tested, artisan quality

✓Insane range: hyper-realistic lifecasts, fantasy creatures, and everything in between

✓Full customization on every toy (firmness, color, size, Vac-U-Lock). It’s basically Build-A-Bear for adults

✓Size range from Xtra Small (5″) to GOLIATH (you’ll need a pep talk and a safe word)

CONS

✗Matte silicone is a lint magnet. You’ll rinse before every use or wonder why your dildo looks furry

✗No returns, no exceptions. Measure twice, buy once

✗Heavy. Solid silicone = arm workout. The larger sizes need their own shelf

✗Starting at $125 for anything good; this is an investment, not an impulse buy

VIXEN CREATIONS

PROS

✓VixSkin dual-density silicone is the most realistic-feeling material in the industry, period

✓Hand-poured in San Francisco with visible attention to detail in every piece

✓100% platinum-cured silicone: completely body-safe, boilable, lasts forever

✓The squish-to-firmness ratio is borderline uncanny: soft skin over a firm core

CONS

✗Extremely expensive. The Maverick runs $120+ and that's mid-range for Vixen

✗The signature line is non-motorized; their vibrating options are a small, newer add-on

✗Limited fantasy or non-realistic options if that's your thing

✗Color selection is narrow compared to competitors like Bad Dragon

WHO SHOULD BUY WHICH

BUY MR HANKEY'S TOYS IF

You want the absolute best silicone quality available, period
Customization matters: firmness, color, size, Vac-U-Lock
You’re into both realistic and fantasy designs (they do both at elite level)

BUY VIXEN CREATIONS IF

Realistic feel is the single most important quality you want in a dildo
Body-safe, non-porous materials are non-negotiable for you
You want a buy-it-for-life product that won't degrade over time

QUESTIONS PEOPLE ASK

Which has better silicone, Mr Hankey's or Vixen?

Both are top-tier platinum-cured silicone. Vixen's VixSkin is the more realistic dual-density feel; Mr Hankey's pours are the finest single-density we've handled, with dual-density available as an option.

Which has more size options?

Mr Hankey's, by a wide margin. Sizes run from Xtra Small (5 inches) to GOLIATH. Vixen's range is realistic proportions in a handful of sizes.

Which is more expensive?

Mr Hankey's, generally. Anything good starts around $125. Vixen runs $80 for the Bandit to $120-plus for the Maverick, which is mid-range for Vixen.

MORE COMPARISONS

Mr Hankey's Toys vs Bad Dragon Mr Hankey's Toys vs Nothosaur Vixen Creations vs Tantus Vixen Creations vs New York Toy Collective Vixen Creations vs Doc Johnson Best Fantasy Dildos All comparisons →

Affiliate links may earn commission. Scores never change for it. Full disclosure.