By SashaThis page contains affiliate links. If you buy through one, we earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes a ranking. How we make money
The short answer
Sliquid H2O (from $10) is the best lube for most people, water-based, safe with every toy and free of glycerin and parabens.
Best overallSliquid H2OFrom $10Buy nowOur review
SiliconeUberlube$21.99Buy nowOur review
Sensitive skinGood Clean Love Almost Naked$16.99Buy nowOur review
AnalSliquid SassyFrom $10Buy nowOur review
Cheaper siliconeSwiss Navy, 8 oz$50.99Buy nowOur review
HybridSliquid SilkFrom $11Buy nowOur reviewThe ranking below sorts the lube makers by overall review score, which counts the formula, shipping, service and value. Under it are the six bottles I'd buy, water against silicone against hybrid, the ingredients to skip and which lube goes with which toy.
Part 1 of 7
“Three ingredients, a clear glass pump bottle, and a formula so invisible you forget you're using lube.”
Also doubles as a legitimately great hair serum, which is how my hairstylist introduced me to it. Can't use it with silicone toys, and that glass bottle in a wet shower is terrifying. But for skin-on-skin, nothing else comes close.
Prices$20–$34
Visit ÜberlubeAffiliate linkRead the Überlube review
Zero glycerin, zero parabens, zero propylene glycol. H2O is the cleanest water-based formula I've found, Sassy is perfect for anal play, and Silk hybrid lasts twice as long as water-based alone. I spent $4 on Astroglide once and $40 on the doctor visit it caused. Sliquid has never sent me to a clinic.
$10–$44
Almost Naked is pH-matched to vaginal tissue (4.0–4.4), which sounds like marketing until you stop getting infections. Organic aloe base, FDA-cleared Restore moisturizer for dryness, available at Target. Narrower range than Sliquid with no silicone lube and just one small hybrid, but the vaginal health science is unmatched.
$12–$26
Lovehoney's own brands on Amazon, sold by Lovehoney, with Amazon's returns rather than the 100-day guarantee lovehoney.com gives. House brand quality is a coin flip below $35, so pick their silicone over $35. The Lifelike Lover Luxe is realistic silicone that isn't a gamble, from $39.99, and the Desire rabbit is $109.99.
Visit LovehoneyAffiliate linkBuy the silicone. Skip everything else. Their silicone formula is thick, smooth, and about 30% cheaper than Uberlube per ounce in the big bottles. The water-based still has parabens in 2026, which is inexcusable when Sliquid H2O costs less. Available practically everywhere, which is its real superpower for in-store shoppers.
Visit Swiss NavyDirect linkSalted caramel is actually good, but every Wicked Aqua flavor lists glycerin second, so keep them to oral. The Simply line is the clean one, with no glycerin, propylene glycol or parabens. Toy Love is a non-drip gel made for toys. Aqua dries out faster than Sliquid H2O and costs more, but nobody beats the variety.
Visit Wicked Sensual CareAffiliate linkPart 2 of 7
Sliquid H2O is the bottle I'd put in every bedroom. It's water-based, so it's safe with silicone, glass, steel and anything else you own, and it skips glycerin, parabens and the other usual irritants. It costs $10 for 2 ounces and $22 for 8.5. The one trade-off is that water-based lube dries out in long sessions, and a few drops of water fix that.
Silicone lasts far longer and doesn't wash off in the shower. Uberlube is the one I'd buy for skin-on-skin, and Swiss Navy's big bottle is the cheapest good silicone per ounce. Keep both away from silicone toys unless the toy's maker says its silicone can take it. If every lube stings, try Good Clean Love's Almost Naked. For anal, use a thicker gel like Sliquid Sassy, because the rectum makes no lube of its own. And if water-based dries out too fast for you but silicone worries you, Sliquid Silk is the middle ground, mostly water with a little silicone.
We earn a commission on some of these links.
Water-based, safe with every toy material, with no glycerin, no parabens and no taste. A few drops of water bring it back when it starts to dry.
Aloe-based and pH-balanced at 4.0 to 4.4, without glycerin or parabens. The one to try if every other lube stings.
H2O's thicker sister. A water-based gel that stays where you put it instead of running, which matters most where the body makes no lube of its own.
The 8-ounce bottle works out to $6.37 an ounce, against $8.94 for Uberlube's big bottle. The 1-ounce is $12.99 if you want to try it first.
Water with a little silicone, so it lasts longer than H2O, and still no glycerin or parabens. The silicone can bother some silicone toys, so test it on a toy's base first.
Product photos: Sliquid, Uberlube, Good Clean Love, Swiss Navy.
Part 3 of 7
Safe with every toy material, easy to clean, and the default choice for most situations. Sliquid H2O (from $10) is the gold standard: no glycerin, no parabens, no taste, no residue. The trade-off is longevity. Water-based lubes dry out during extended sessions as the water evaporates. A few drops of water reactivate most formulas without reapplying from the bottle. If you own silicone toys, water-based is your safe default.
Uberlube ($22 for 55ml) is one product that does one thing perfectly. A single drop lasts through an entire session without reapplying. The silky feel is different from water-based, more like a glide than a wet surface. Perfect for shower or bath play because water doesn't wash it away. The catch is that silicone lube can damage some silicone toys and leave a tacky, warped surface. Use it for skin-on-skin, with glass, steel, or ABS plastic toys, or with a silicone toy whose maker says it's fine. pjur Woman is another silicone bottle worth knowing. It's $25.60 for 100 ml on Amazon, and pjur rates it safe with latex, polyurethane and polyisoprene condoms.
Written by DanielLube comes in 1.86 ounces here, 4.2 there and 112 milliliters somewhere else, which is how a $22 bottle of Uberlube costs more per ounce than the $34 one. Divided out at the makers' own prices, the picture gets simple.
Water-based runs $3 to $5 an ounce and silicone $6 to $9, but silicone goes further because it doesn't dry out halfway through. Sliquid H2O, the gold standard above, is also the cheapest good water-based bottle by almost a dollar an ounce. For silicone, the big Swiss Navy bottle beats everything else in the column.
Water-based with a small percentage of silicone added for longevity. Sliquid Silk is the best-known hybrid. Lasts longer than pure water-based without the full toy-compatibility restrictions of silicone. The silicone in it can still damage some silicone toys, so patch-test on the base first, or default to pure water-based for silicone toys you want to protect.
Thicker gel formulas that stay in place instead of running. Sliquid Sassy is formulated specifically for anal play: same clean ingredients as H2O, thicker consistency that doesn't migrate. The rectum doesn't self-lubricate, so running out of lube during anal means friction and potential tearing. Gel lubes solve this. Apply more than you think you need.
Part 4 of 7
Most people grab whatever's on the drugstore shelf and never check the label. That's how you end up with recurring infections and no idea why.
Glycerin feeds yeast. It's in KY Jelly, Astroglide, and most cheap water-based lubes. If you or a partner is prone to yeast infections, glycerin-containing lube is often the trigger nobody thinks to eliminate. Sliquid and Good Clean Love's water-based lubes skip it entirely.
Parabens are hormone disruptors that accumulate in tissue with repeated exposure. The research on long-term effects is still evolving, but the precautionary case is strong enough that multiple health and consumer-safety groups have raised flags. Easy to avoid, since clean-ingredient brands cost only a few dollars more.
Propylene glycol irritates sensitive skin and mucous membranes in a percentage of people. Chlorhexidine kills beneficial bacteria along with harmful ones, disrupting vaginal flora. Nonoxynol-9 is a spermicide that causes inflammation and paradoxically increases infection risk by damaging the tissue barrier.
Sliquid avoids all of the above. Good Clean Love's water-based lubes avoid all of the above and add pH balancing. Wicked Sensual Care Simply line avoids all of the above. Spending a few dollars more on a bottle of lube that won't cause problems is the easiest health decision in this entire category.
Part 5 of 7
This is the single most common mistake people make with lube, and it ruins expensive toys.
Silicone lube can damage the surface of some silicone toys. When it does, the toy can turn sticky or swell, in Uberlube's words, and Fun Factory warns that silicone lube is hard to wash off a toy completely, which is a problem for something you want to keep body-safe. Water-based lube is safe with every material: silicone, glass, steel, ABS plastic, even TPE (thermoplastic elastomer)A soft, cheap material used for most stroker sleeves. It's porous, so it can't be fully sanitized, and a sleeve lasts about a year of regular use. More in the glossary if you still have older toys.
Oil-based lubes (including coconut oil) degrade latex condoms. If condoms are part of your setup, stick to water-based. Oil also stains fabrics permanently and can disrupt vaginal pH.
The simple rule: water-based is the universal default. Keep silicone lube for skin-on-skin sex (it's fine with latex and polyisoprene condoms) and for toys whose maker says their silicone can take it. Here's what 17 toy makers say, and only two of them say yes. If you own one bottle, make it water-based. If you own two, add silicone for specific situations. My complete lube guide has the full compatibility chart, and there's a one-page version to print.
Part 6 of 7
Part 7 of 7
Sliquid H2O (from $10) for most people. It's water-based, safe with every toy, and free of glycerin and parabens. For silicone, Uberlube ($21.99). For sensitive skin, Good Clean Love's Almost Naked ($16.99). For anal, Sliquid Sassy (from $10). For cheaper silicone, Swiss Navy (8 ounces for $50.99). For a hybrid, Sliquid Silk (from $11).
Sliquid H2O, with no glycerin or parabens, from $10 for 2 ounces. If you react to everything, Good Clean Love's Almost Naked is pH-balanced and aloe-based. For anal, Sliquid's thicker Sassy gel stays put longer.
Water-based, every time you're not sure. Sliquid H2O is safe with every material. Silicone lube can damage some silicone toys and not others, so use it only when the toy's maker says yes. SquarePeg and Mr Hankey's say theirs can take it, while Vixen and Aneros say no silicone lube on their silicone. Our maker-by-maker list has the rest.
Uberlube ($21.99 for 55 ml), three silicones and vitamin E in a glass pump bottle, and one drop goes a long way. Swiss Navy's Premium Silicone costs less per ounce in the big bottles, $50.99 for 8 ounces. Both are fine with latex condoms, and neither belongs on a silicone toy whose maker hasn't said so.
Water-based is safe with all toy materials and easy to clean up. Silicone lasts much longer (doesn't dry out or absorb) and is better for shower or water play, but it can damage silicone toys unless the toy's maker says it's fine. For silicone toys, water-based. For partnered sex without toys, silicone is a better experience. Full breakdown with specific product recommendations in my lube guide.
Glycerin (feeds yeast, causes infections for many people), parabens (hormone disruptors that accumulate in tissue), propylene glycol (irritant for sensitive skin), chlorhexidine (kills beneficial bacteria), and nonoxynol-9 (spermicide that irritates and inflames tissue). Sliquid avoids all of these and is my default recommendation. Good Clean Love is another clean-ingredient brand worth considering.
Water-based lubes dry out as the water evaporates, which creates a sticky residue. This is normal. Adding a few drops of water (or saliva, let's be real) reactivates most water-based lubes without needing to reapply from the bottle. Silicone lubes don't have this problem because there's no water to evaporate. If stickiness bothers you, try a hybrid lube (water-based with a small percentage of silicone) for a smoother feel.
For skin-on-skin contact without condoms, coconut oil works fine and many people love it. But it degrades latex condoms (making them break), stains fabrics permanently, and can cause infections in people prone to them because oil disrupts vaginal pH. It won't hurt silicone toys, but it's hard to wash out of textured surfaces. For anything involving condoms or toys, stick with a purpose-made lube.
More than you think. Start with a dime-sized amount and add more as needed. For anal play, double that. For toy use, apply to both yourself and the toy. Reapply whenever friction increases. There is no upper limit where lube becomes a problem, but there is a lower limit where not enough causes discomfort, friction burns, or microtears. When in doubt, add more.
Yes. Most water-based lubes last 1-2 years after opening, silicone lubes a bit longer. Check the expiration date on the bottle. Expired lube can grow bacteria (especially water-based formulas) or change consistency. If it smells different, has changed color, or has separated in the bottle, throw it out. Store at room temperature, out of direct sunlight, and keep the cap clean.
Sliquid Organics Natural or Good Clean Love Almost Naked. Both skip glycerin, parabens, and propylene glycol, which are the three most common irritants. Aloe-based lubes tend to be gentler than glycol-based ones. If you react to everything, try a patch test on your inner wrist before using any new lube internally. Sensitivity varies by person, but clean-ingredient brands minimize the risk.
Water-based and silicone-based lubes are both safe with latex and polyisoprene condoms. Oil-based lubes (including coconut oil and Vaseline) degrade latex and will cause condoms to break. If you're using condoms, stick with water-based to be safe with everything. A drop of lube inside the condom tip before rolling it on improves sensation for the wearer. A drop outside improves it for both partners. My lube guide has the full compatibility chart.
Head-to-heads between makers on this list:
A short email from the two of us once a month: what we still use, what let us down, and one reader question.
One email a month. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy
