Editorial Guidelines
How we write, check and correct everything on The Toy Slut
These are the rules we work by. They cover what each kind of page rests on, how we check facts, what we do with gifts from brands, how we make money and what happens when we get something wrong. If you find a page that breaks one of them, tell us.
Who we are
The Toy Slut is Sasha and Daniel, a married couple, and the two of us are the only people who set a score here. Every review, guide and ranking says at the top which of us stands behind it. More about us is on the About page, and the story of how this started is in Why We Started The Toy Slut.
How we use AI
We use AI tools for research, for quality checks and for parts of the site's code. The experiences in our product reviews are our own, and so are the scores.
What each kind of page rests on
Product reviews cover one toy we've used ourselves, with our own photos. Each of us who used it gives our own score, and the review tells you how we used it.
Brand reviews score a maker or a store as a whole: what it makes, the materials, the prices, the shipping, the returns and the service. Some are profiles built from what a brand publishes, its policies and public records rather than from our own use, and the byline says so.
Rankings sort the brands in a category by score. Twelve of them use a score built for that kind of toy, which How We Test explains part by part. When two brands have the same score, they share the place, and we don't call either of them the winner.
Guides help you choose or use something. When a guide names a product, we read its price on the store's own page on the day we write or update the guide, because prices move every week.
Research pages collect public data, such as the listed prices of 14,659 toys or the return rules of 56 makers and shops, and show the method on the page. Three of them come with the data as a free CSV file.
Explainers answer a question, like whether silicone lube is safe on silicone toys, from published research and the makers' own guidance, with the sources linked in the text.
Editorials are about us and how we work, and say so. They sell nothing.
How we check facts
Prices and specs come from the maker's or the store's own page, read on the day. When two of a maker's own pages disagree, we tell you both instead of picking the nicer one.
Materials and safety claims are the maker's, and we name them as the maker's. Almost no maker publishes a lab test of a finished toy, so a missing report is something we tell you, not a reason to mark a brand down. When a maker does post a report, we read it and say what it covers.
Studies and statistics are linked at the source, the study itself rather than a news story about it, and we say so when a study is small.
Return, warranty and shipping rules are read on the brand's own pages and judged against what's normal. Most makers won't take back an opened toy, for hygiene reasons, so that alone costs no one points. A policy counts against a brand only when it's worse than the norm.
Allegations we can't check stay out, or get one neutral sentence when readers need to know they exist. They never count in a score.
Links to other sites are checked by a script every time we publish, and a dead link stops the update until we fix it.
Health and law. We're not doctors or lawyers. What we say about health comes from the medical sources we link, and what we say about the law comes from the laws, court rulings and legal summaries we link.
Gifts, samples and brands
Some toys we review are gifts from the brand or a store. The review says so right under the byline, and a gift doesn't change a score. When we ask a brand for samples, we let it choose what it thinks represents it best.
No brand sees a review before it's published. Afterwards a brand can point out a factual error, and we fix facts, not opinions. When a brand answers our questions, we work the answers in and say that it answered.
How we make money
We earn from affiliate links, labeled ads and sponsored reviews. When you buy through one of our links, the store pays us a commission and you pay the same price. Most of our buy buttons go to stores that pay us, and the price we show is the price at the store the button goes to, on the day we checked. Pages with affiliate links say so near the top.
The banners on our pages are our own affiliate banners for products we recommend elsewhere on the site, marked Advertisement. A brand can also buy a labeled ad, but never on its own review.
A sponsored review is a review a brand pays to have published on a set date. It's labeled as sponsored at the top, it's scored like every other review, and the brand doesn't see it first. It can come with a place on the rankings the product belongs in, but the order there comes from the score, the same as for everyone else.
No one can buy a score, a verdict, a ranking position, a look at a draft or a link that isn't labeled. The details are on our disclosure page and, for brands, on the partnerships page.
Photos
The photos in our product reviews are our own. Elsewhere we use the makers' own product photos and credit them under the picks and tables, and a homepage cover can be a stock photo we've edited.
What we won't cover
We don't rank, link or name makers whose stores sell dolls or other products framed or sized as children, whatever they pay. Nothing sexual on the site involves minors, family members, animals or anyone who hasn't agreed. We also don't explain how to do breath play or choking, because there's no safe version of either.
Dates and updates
Every review and guide shows the day it was published, and the day it was last updated when that's later. The Updated date changes when the text changes, a fact, a price or a section, and not when we only swap a link.
Corrections
If something on the site is wrong, tell us or email sasha@thetoyslut.com. We check the claim against its source, fix the page and change its Updated date. These are some of the corrections we've made recently.
- November 15, 2026. Our statistics page listed "ER visits for sex toy injuries doubled" among the numbers that don't hold up. A 2021 study of emergency room records shows the rise, so we took the claim off that list and added the study to the injury table.
- November 9, 2026. We had written that Nothosaur costs about half of what Bad Dragon charges. Matched size for size, most of its toys cost about the same as Bad Dragon's, and the pages now say so.
- October 31, 2026. Our Bad Dragon review said every toy except a Flop comes with a one-year warranty. Its masturbators have none, and the review now says which toys are covered.
- October 31, 2026. We called Vixen's Ride On a VixSkin toy. Vixen pours it in a softer platinum silicone, and the review and the strap-on ranking now say so.
- October 24, 2026. We gave LELO's warranty as one year. LELO gives two, and adds a year in some countries when you register the toy.
- October 23, 2026. We named Abyss Creations as RealDoll's parent company. Realbotix said in July 2026 that its subsidiary Intima LLC holds 86% of RealDoll.
- October 16, 2026. Our pages said silicone lube ruins silicone toys. It can harm some of them, depending on the lube and the silicone, so we corrected every page that said so, and ten days later we published what 22 makers say about it.
Questions
Questions about these rules go to sasha@thetoyslut.com or the contact form. Our scoring method is on How We Test.

