Black Friday274 toys cost less than in OctoberSee the deals

SquarePeg Toys Review: The Squishiest Silicone in the Game (And Why That Matters)

The short answer

Nobody else makes this material. The Egg Plug medium is the place to start.

8.2

Great · out of 10 · how we score

#4 of 7 in Anal Toys

Tested the Egg Plug, the Slink Small and the Leo

How it scored

  • Product Quality9.0
  • Material Innovation10.0
  • Design & Variety8.0
  • Value for Money8.0
  • Size Range9.0
  • Website & Ordering7.0

What's good

  • SuperSoft silicone is unlike anything else on the market: compresses, stretches, and forgives like no other material
  • Egg Plug is the single best anal plug design for comfortable extended wear
  • Slink series opens up depth play in a way rigid toys physically cannot
  • Every product is platinum-cured silicone, made in the USA, zero compromises on safety
  • Size progression is thoughtful across every product line, from modest to ambitious
  • Prices are reasonable for handmade platinum silicone, especially compared to competitors

What's not

  • SuperSoft firmness is TOO soft for some applications: thrusting with Slinks requires patience
  • Website looks like it was designed in 2009 and hasn't been updated since
  • Limited color options compared to Bad Dragon or Mr Hankey's custom pours
  • No vibrating options anywhere in the lineup
  • Matte silicone collects lint and dust like a magnet
  • Some models only available in SuperSoft, no firm option for people who prefer structure

Bottom line: SquarePeg invented a silicone formulation that makes larger toys approachable and depth play possible. Nobody else has this material, and for anal enthusiasts, that alone makes them essential.

I squeezed my first SquarePeg Egg Plug and watched it flatten to a pancake in my palm. Then I let go, and it popped back to shape like nothing happened. I sat there for a full minute just squishing it, fascinated, before remembering I was supposed to be reviewing it.

SquarePeg Toys is a small American manufacturer that does one thing nobody else in the industry does: they make Platinum-cure siliconeSilicone set with a platinum catalyst instead of tin. It cures cleaner, with nothing left over, and it's the claim to look for on a silicone toy. More in the glossary silicone so soft it compresses under its own weight. They call it SuperSoft, which sounds like a laundry detergent but is actually a proprietary silicone formulation that changes the math on what sizes your body can handle. The material yields, compresses, folds around you instead of pushing against you. Physics still applies, but it's more polite about it.

The company has been around for over two decades, quietly building a cult following in the anal and size-play communities while flashier brands grabbed headlines. No viral marketing. No influencer deals. Just a small workshop turning out some of the most innovative silicone toys on the market for people who know what they're looking for.

Their lineup covers plugs (the legendary Egg Plug), depth toys (the Slink series), and more conventional shapes (the Leo). Everything is body-safe platinum silicone. Everything ships from the USA. And that SuperSoft formulation is the reason we're here.

Part 1 of 11 · 2 min

The SuperSoft silicone

SquarePeg's SuperSoft doesn't push back.

SuperSoft silicone is SquarePeg's entire identity, and for good reason. Standard platinum-cured silicone from brands like Mr Hankey's or Tantus comes in firmness levels ranging from slightly yielding to rock-hard. Even the softest options from those brands maintain their shape under pressure. You push, the silicone pushes back.

SquarePeg's SuperSoft doesn't push back. It collapses, compresses, folds in on itself. You can squeeze an Egg Plug down to half its resting diameter with one hand. During insertion, the material deforms around your anatomy rather than demanding your anatomy accommodate it. The practical result: toys that measure intimidating on paper feel manageable in practice. A 3-inch diameter Egg Plug in SuperSoft might only require the same relaxation as a 2-inch plug in standard silicone, because the material does half the work for you.

This isn't a gimmick. The Pelvic floorThe muscles that hold up the bladder, bowel and uterus or prostate. They contract during orgasm, and Kegel exercises or weighted balls train them. More in the glossary muscles and anal sphincter respond differently to yielding pressure versus rigid pressure. A firm object demands active relaxation from the muscle to allow passage. A soft object reduces the force required because it deforms before the muscle does. For people working on size progression, this is the difference between a frustrating plateau and a gradual, comfortable advance. The muscle still stretches. The experience just doesn't hurt.

The tradeoff is real, though. SuperSoft silicone provides almost zero internal pressure once inserted. If you want that feeling of firm fullness from a plug, where the material actively presses against your walls, SuperSoft won't deliver it. It's there, you know it's there, but it's more of a gentle presence than an insistent one. Some people find this perfect for extended wear. Others find it underwhelming after the insertion is over.

Tip

SuperSoft is best for: insertion comfort, size progression, extended wear, and depth play. It's NOT the best for: firm fullness, strong internal pressure, or thrusting with resistance. Know what you want before you buy.

The material also has a distinctive feel in your hands. Where standard silicone feels like, well, silicone, SuperSoft feels closer to a stress ball or memory foam. It's weirdly satisfying to handle. Daniel picked up the Egg Plug off my desk, spent five minutes squishing it, and said 'I don't even use this and I want one.' The tactile quality alone sets it apart from every other toy material I've encountered.

Part 2 of 11 · 2 min

The Egg Plug

The Egg Plug is about disappearing, the Snug Plug is about being constantly felt.

The Egg Plug is SquarePeg's signature product and the reason most people discover the brand. It's an egg-shaped plug (shocking, I know) available in nine sizes from XS to Monster, in SuperSoft silicone or, up to the XL, SquarePeg's Firmer Black. The design is so simple it seems like it shouldn't be special. It's an egg. On a stem. With a base.

SquarePeg Toys logo

The signature product

Egg Plug

An egg of SuperSoft silicone on a narrow stem, with a thin, flexible base.

  • 1.5 inmax diameter, small
  • 8 hrsof wear in the medium, forgot it twice
  • 11.3 inaround, the Monster
  • $29–$159XS to Monster

Also in the lineup

  • Slink · from $69
  • Leo · $59–$257

But the egg shape combined with SuperSoft silicone creates something no traditional plug can replicate. Once past the sphincter, the egg settles into place and the SuperSoft material conforms to your internal anatomy rather than holding a fixed shape. It's like the difference between sitting on a wooden chair and sitting on a bean bag. Both support you. One adapts to you.

I wore the medium Egg Plug for an entire workday. Eight hours, sitting at a desk, walking to get coffee, standing in line at the post office. Forgot it was there twice. That's never happened with a standard firmness plug, where I'm always aware of the rigid shape pressing against my body from the inside. The SuperSoft egg just... exists. Quietly. Comfortably. The narrow stem between the egg and the base means your sphincter closes around almost nothing, which eliminates that constant stretch sensation that makes other plugs fatiguing over hours.

The base is thin and flexible, following the same SuperSoft philosophy. It tucks between your cheeks without creating a visible ridge under clothing and doesn't dig into your skin when you sit. b-Vibe's Snug Plugs have a similarly well-designed base for extended wear, but those are weighted and firm, which is a different experience entirely. The Egg Plug is about disappearing, the Snug Plug is about being constantly felt.

“I wore this to the post office. Nobody knew. I barely knew. That's the whole point of the Egg Plug.”

Sasha, on extended wear

Sizing on the Egg Plug deserves attention. The small is about 1.5 inches max diameter (the XS about 1.3), which is a near-beginner size. The Monster is 11.3 inches around, about 3.6 across, which is not. Because SuperSoft compresses so much, people sometimes jump sizes too aggressively, thinking 'well it's soft, so the next size up should be fine.' Your body still needs time to adapt. The softness of the material doesn't eliminate the need for patience; it just makes each step more comfortable. If you're new to anal play, our beginner anal guide covers the progression principles that apply regardless of what material you're working with.

Part 4 of 11 · 2 min

Leo series

I found it most useful for vaginal use, where the SuperSoft material has a different advantage than it does anally.

Not everything SquarePeg makes is for the advanced crowd. The Leo is their most conventional product: dildo-shaped, shaft-and-head proportions, available in SuperSoft and, in the harness version, SquarePeg's slightly firmer Firmer Black.

The shape is uncircumcised realistic with a defined head and gentle texture along the shaft. Nothing extreme. Nothing weird. Just a well-proportioned dildo in a material that feels unlike any other dildo you've handled. In SuperSoft, the Leo compresses during penetration, creating a sensation that's softer and more forgiving than standard silicone but still provides enough shape to feel present. It's the middle ground between 'is anything even in there?' and 'oh god that's firm.'

I found it most useful for vaginal use, where the SuperSoft material has a different advantage than it does anally. Vaginally, the softness means the toy conforms around the G-spot area rather than pressing a fixed shape against it. Some people prefer that conforming sensation to a rigid toy that hits one specific spot. Others find it too diffuse and want something with more backbone. Vixen Creations' VixSkin line handles this better with their Dual-density siliconeA soft outer layer poured over a firmer core, so the toy gives like skin on the surface and still holds its shape. More in the glossary approach: soft exterior, firm core. The Leo is soft all the way through.

For anal use, the Leo works but doesn't outperform the Egg Plug for plugging or the Slink for depth. If you're buying one SquarePeg product and you're interested in anal, get the Egg Plug. If you want a soft dildo for vaginal use or you're curious about the SuperSoft feel without committing to a specialized shape, the Leo is the right entry point.

Sizes run from XS (5.6 inches tall, in the harness version) through King. The XS and Small sell best, which makes sense: at those sizes, SuperSoft is a texture novelty. At the larger sizes, SuperSoft becomes a practical tool for making ambitious dimensions achievable.

Part 5 of 11 · 1 min

Size progression

Think of it as the intermediate-to-advanced toolkit rather than the starter kit.

SquarePeg's product range is built around progression, and it's one of the most thoughtful size ladders in the industry. Within the Egg Plug line alone, you can go from a small that's appropriate for near-beginners to an XXL that's firmly in advanced territory, all in the same shape and material. That consistency matters. When you size up and the only variable that changes is diameter, you can isolate exactly how much more your body is handling without confounding factors like different shapes, firmness levels, or materials.

Note

The community-recommended progression for anal beginners: Small Egg Plug (2-4 weeks) -> Medium Egg Plug (2-4 weeks) -> Large Egg Plug or Slink Small (depending on whether you want girth or depth). SuperSoft makes each jump more forgiving, but time between sizes still matters.

What SquarePeg doesn't do well is the very beginning of the journey. Their smallest Egg Plug, while modest by SquarePeg standards, is still a step above what a true beginner with zero anal experience should start with. For someone who has never inserted anything anally, a b-Vibe Snug Plug 1 or a slim silicone plug from Tantus is the safer first step. SquarePeg's lineup picks up where those introductory products leave off. Think of it as the intermediate-to-advanced toolkit rather than the starter kit.

The community around SquarePeg is smaller than Bad Dragon's but remarkably helpful. Reddit threads on size progression with SuperSoft products include timelines, personal experiences, and specific size-up advice that you won't find on the company's website. If you're serious about progression, spend an hour reading community experiences before ordering. The collective wisdom is worth more than any product description.

Part 6 of 11 · 2 min

Care & maintenance

Store upright when possible, or lay it flat with nothing pressing against it.

Platinum-cured silicone care applies universally here. Porous and nonporousPorous materials like TPE, jelly and Cyberskin have tiny pores that can hold bacteria. Nonporous ones like silicone, glass and steel can be cleaned completely. More in the glossary surface means soap and warm water handles daily cleaning. For full sterilization between partners or between anal and vaginal use, boiling for 3-5 minutes kills almost everything. Top rack of a dishwasher works too (no soap, no other dishes). A 10% bleach solution followed by thorough rinsing is the nuclear option for the truly cautious.

SuperSoft silicone has one care consideration that standard silicone doesn't: deformation during storage. Because the material is so yielding, leaving a SuperSoft toy under weight or pressed against a surface for extended periods can cause temporary (sometimes permanent) warping. An Egg Plug stored on its side with a heavy book on top will flatten slightly on that side over weeks. Store upright when possible, or lay it flat with nothing pressing against it. The warping isn't structural damage, and a light dent may ease out over a few days at room temperature, but SquarePeg says creases and imprints can become permanent, which is worse than annoying.

Lint is the same problem you get with any matte silicone, amplified by the softness. SuperSoft's surface has more micro-texture than standard silicone, giving dust and fibers extra grip. A quick rinse before use becomes habit fast. Storage in a clear plastic container, which is what SquarePeg itself suggests instead of cloth wraps, prevents the worst of it. Do not store SuperSoft toys touching vinyl or any other non-silicone toy, or in a box that once held vinyl; the plasticizers get onto the surface and dissolve the silicone into goo.

Tip

Cornstarch (NOT talcum powder, which has health concerns) can be lightly dusted on SuperSoft silicone for storage to reduce surface tackiness and lint attraction. Rinse thoroughly before use. This is a common trick in the community that SquarePeg doesn't officially recommend but also doesn't discourage.

Lube compatibility is where SquarePeg breaks the usual rule: water-based is the easy default, but SquarePeg says silicone lube has never damaged its toys. Other silicone toy makers still warn that silicone lube damages silicone toys over time; SquarePeg calls that a myth and reports no problems since SuperSoft launched in 2006. The real catch is cleaning, and it matters more on SuperSoft: silicone lube is hard to wash off entirely, and on that micro-texture the leftover film traps odors and bacteria. One session with silicone lube won't ruin the toy. Repeated exposure means a Dawn scrub every time. Just use water-based. The extra reapplication is a minor inconvenience compared to degreasing a $59 plug.

Part 7 of 11 · 2 min

vs. the competition

They do one thing (ultra-soft platinum silicone) better than anyone on the planet.

SquarePeg vs. b-Vibe is the comparison that comes up most for anal-focused buyers, and the answer is simple: they serve different purposes. b-Vibe makes the best vibrating and weighted plugs on the market, with education resources that hold beginners' hands through the entire learning curve. SquarePeg makes the best ultra-soft silicone for size progression and extended wear. If you want vibration, buy b-Vibe. If you want the softest material available, buy SquarePeg. There's almost no overlap. Many serious anal enthusiasts own products from both.

SquarePeg vs. Mr Hankey's is a material philosophy debate. Mr Hankey's platinum silicone is denser, more detailed, and available in multiple firmness levels from yielding to rock-solid. Their customization options crush SquarePeg's limited lineup. But Mr Hankey's softest firmness isn't even close to SuperSoft. If you've hit a size plateau with standard silicone and need a material that gives more, SquarePeg is the only answer. If you want the highest quality, most detailed dildo in a firmness that still has structure, Mr Hankey's wins.

Bad Dragon offers a soft firmness option that some people compare to SuperSoft. Having handled both, they're not equivalent. Bad Dragon's soft is yielding but still maintains its shape under gravity. SquarePeg's SuperSoft flattens under its own weight. The difference is significant in practice: Bad Dragon soft compresses maybe 20-30% during insertion, while SuperSoft compresses 40-50% or more. For pure softness, SquarePeg is in a class by itself. For fantasy designs, color options, and community, Bad Dragon wins easily.

Compression on insertion

40-50%

Bad Dragon soft compresses maybe 20-30% during insertion, while SuperSoft compresses 40-50% or more.

Tantus doesn't really compete in the same space. Tantus makes excellent Body-safe siliconePure silicone with no fillers. It's nonporous, so it cleans completely, and "platinum-cured" on the listing is the best sign you're getting the real thing. More in the glossary at budget prices, but their firmness range tops out at 'slightly soft.' If you just want a reliable, affordable plug or dildo in proven platinum silicone, Tantus is the practical choice.

“SuperSoft isn't better or worse than standard silicone. Comparing them is like comparing a hammer to a pillow. Both useful, wildly different applications.”

Sasha, on material philosophy

The honest positioning: SquarePeg is a specialist. They do one thing (ultra-soft platinum silicone) better than anyone on the planet. If that thing is what you need, there's no alternative. If it's not, broader-catalog brands like b-Vibe or Mr Hankey's will serve you better.

Part 8 of 11 · 2 min

Website & ordering

Credit where it's due: the content is useful even if the presentation is ugly.

The SquarePeg website looks like it was built during the Obama administration and hasn't been touched since. It functions. Products load. The cart works. But the design is dated, navigation is clunky, and the photography ranges from adequate to 'did you take this with a flip phone?'

Product descriptions are informative but dense. They explain the SuperSoft material well for first-time buyers, include accurate measurements, and provide honest sizing guidance. Credit where it's due: the content is useful even if the presentation is ugly. Some brands have gorgeous websites with zero substance. SquarePeg has the opposite problem.

Ordering is painless, with no monthly cap like the one on Bad Dragon custom orders. No drops. No limited windows, except on the Limited Release shapes, which get made twice a year, in June and December (sign up and they tell you when one is back). You browse, you select, you buy. Stock levels vary and popular sizes sell out, but the restocking cadence is reasonable. Shipping is from the US, standard packaging, no branding on the box. Delivery times run about a week domestically.

The biggest website gripe: no star ratings. Customer reviews do sit in a tab on each product page, but they run oldest first (the Egg Plug's 45 start in 2013), so the recent ones are buried at the bottom. This pushes buyers to Reddit and forums for real user feedback, which actually provides better information than curated on-site reviews anyway, but it's a gap in the buying experience that most modern shops have filled. When you're spending $60-100 on a toy in an unusual material, reading that twelve other people found the medium perfect for extended wear is reassuring. SquarePeg makes you dig for that reassurance.

Part 9 of 11 · 2 min

Pricing & value

SquarePeg's pricing lands in the lower half of the premium silicone market while offering a material that nobody else makes.

SquarePeg surprised me by costing less than I expected. Egg Plugs start at $29 for the XS and climb to $159 for the Monster. Slinks run from about $69 to several hundred depending on length and diameter. Leo dildos run $59 to $257, from the XS harness version up to the King.

Compare that to the competition. A b-Vibe Snug Plug runs $49.99-$89.99 for a non-vibrating silicone plug. A Mr Hankey's dildo starts at $65.95 for an XS, and the Perfect Penis at $125.95. A Bad Dragon medium dildo costs $130 before add-ons. SquarePeg's pricing lands in the lower half of the premium silicone market while offering a material that nobody else makes.

SquarePeg against premium silicone, by starting price
  1. Egg Plug, XS$29

    Climbs to $159 for the Monster. Small, medium and large together run $147.

  2. b-Vibe Snug Plug$49.99–$89.99

    A non-vibrating silicone plug. Not SquarePeg, here for scale.

  3. Mr Hankey's XS dildo$65.95

    The Perfect Penis is $125.95.

  4. Slinkfrom about $69

    Up to several hundred, depending on length and diameter.

  5. Bad Dragon medium dildo$130

    Before add-ons.

The XS Egg Plug undercuts the smallest b-Vibe Snug Plug by $21.

Prices as quoted in this review, updated October 2026.

Where it gets tricky is the lack of bundles or progression sets. b-Vibe sells the Snug Plug system as a set with a discount. SquarePeg sells each size individually at full price. Building a three-size Egg Plug progression (small, medium, large) runs $147 total ($39, $49 and $59). Not unreasonable for three platinum silicone products, but a bundled option at a slight discount would move more product and serve customers better.

“Three platinum silicone plugs for the price of one Mr Hankey's custom pour. The value math is friendlier than you'd expect from a specialist brand.”

Sasha, on pricing

The durability argument applies here too. Platinum-cured silicone doesn't degrade. A $39 Egg Plug that lasts indefinitely costs less per year than the cheap TPE (thermoplastic elastomer)A soft, cheap material used for most stroker sleeves. It's porous, so it can't be fully sanitized, and a sleeve lasts about a year of regular use. More in the glossary plugs people replace every few months when they start smelling weird or developing that sticky film. Body-safe materials cost more upfront and less over time. SquarePeg's prices make that calculus easier than most premium brands.

Part 10 of 11 · 1 min

Who should buy from SquarePeg Toys?

Get one if

  • You've hit a size plateau with standard silicone and need a material that gives more
  • Extended plug wear is your thing and comfort over hours matters most
  • Depth play interests you and you want the safest, most flexible tool for it
  • You value body-safe platinum silicone but don't want to spend Mr Hankey's prices
  • You're in the intermediate-to-advanced range and want a progression system that grows with you

Skip if

  • You're a complete beginner with zero anal experience (start with b-Vibe or Tantus first)
  • You want vibration, app control, or any electronic features
  • You prefer firm internal pressure and fullness over soft, conforming comfort
  • Extensive color customization and detailed designs matter to you
  • You want a polished shopping experience with star ratings and modern UX
Sasha

Sasha's verdict

8.2

out of 10 · how we score

Most sex toy brands compete on the same axis: who has the prettiest design, the most vibration patterns, the sleekest app integration. SquarePeg looked at all of that and decided to compete on material science instead. They invented a silicone formulation that doesn't exist anywhere else in the industry, and built an entire product line around the specific advantages that material provides.

That's a weird strategy. It's also a brilliant one.

The Egg Plug in SuperSoft is the most comfortable anal plug I've ever worn for extended periods. Not the most stimulating, not the most innovative in its design, just the most comfortable. The Slink series makes depth play accessible in a way that rigid toys physically cannot, because the material follows your body's curves instead of fighting them. The Leo line proves that SuperSoft works for conventional shapes too, even if it's not the best at that application.

The downsides are real. The website needs a full redesign. Color options are limited. There's no vibration in anything they make. The SuperSoft material, for all its advantages during insertion, provides less internal pressure than standard silicone once it's in place. And if you're a true beginner with zero anal experience, SquarePeg's smallest offerings are still a step beyond where you should start; b-Vibe or a basic Tantus plug is the better first purchase.

Nobody else makes this material. If you've been bumping against a size ceiling with standard silicone, if extended plug wear has always been uncomfortable, if depth play interests you but rigid toys intimidate you, SquarePeg solves problems that no other brand even attempts to address. The Egg Plug medium is the place to start. Your body will tell you whether SuperSoft is your thing within the first five minutes. For a lot of people, it becomes the only thing.

Tested: 5 weeks · Updated October 19, 2026

Frequently Asked Questions

What makes SquarePeg's SuperSoft silicone different?

It compresses under its own weight. You can squeeze an Egg Plug flat in your palm and it pops right back. Standard silicone pushes back against you; SuperSoft deforms around your anatomy. A 2.5-inch toy in SuperSoft feels nothing like a 2.5-inch toy in firm silicone.

Is SquarePeg's SuperSoft silicone body-safe?

Yes. Platinum-cured silicone, made in the USA. The softness is a formulation difference, not a safety compromise. Same body-safe material as any premium silicone brand.

SquarePeg Egg Plug vs a regular silicone butt plug?

The Egg Plug in SuperSoft compresses during insertion and then gently expands once seated. Standard plugs demand that your body accommodate them. For extended wear or size progression, the Egg Plug is in a different league.

Can I use SquarePeg Slinks for depth play?

That's exactly what they're built for. The SuperSoft silicone flexes and bends with your body's curves instead of fighting them. Rigid toys can't follow your anatomy the way these do.

SquarePeg vs Mr. Hankey's vs Bad Dragon?

Mr. Hankey's wins on detail and size range. Bad Dragon wins on fantasy designs, colors and add-ons. SquarePeg wins on material innovation. If SuperSoft silicone is what you need, nobody else makes it.

Where next

The monthly letter

A short email from the two of us once a month: what we still use, what let us down, and one reader question.

One email a month. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy